Back to discography

Pastorale

2021Berlin Classics

Works by Beethoven (arr. Liszt)

Much has already been said about music in times of pandemic. Everyone who earns a living with music has dealt with the situation differently — reflecting on themselves, drawing attention online to themselves and their situation, or throwing themselves into even greater activity than before. The Germany-based US pianist Claire Huangci used her time during the pandemic to engage deeply with Liszt's keyboard transcriptions of Beethoven's symphonies, recording the Sixth Symphony — the 'Pastorale' — in summer 2020 in the studio of SWR2. Transforming orchestral complexity into solo piano work represents an opportunity to explore familiar compositions anew: while transcriptions cannot fully replace orchestral performance, they offer valuable insights and fresh interpretations. Huangci's approach to this programmatic work is deeply personal. The symphony's movements depict pastoral scenes — vom Erwachen heiterer Empfindungen über eine Szene am Bach, dem lustigen Zusammensein der Landleute und dem berühmten Gewitter zum Hirtengesang (from the awakening of cheerful feelings through a scene by the brook, the merry gathering of country folk and the famous thunderstorm to the shepherd's song) — providing an optimistic perspective on the year ahead.

Press

In the Andante molto (Scene by the Brook) the melody unfolds between bass and treble under Claire Huangci's hands the unclouded lyricism of Beethoven's soul-life. In the brisk Scherzo, the merry festival of the country folk comes alive. Delightful how the nimble runs energetically, expressively and with nuance characterise this scene. Finally thunder, storm: in the Allegro the entire virtuosity is mustered. Hands and fingers fly up and down until, after a musical rain shower, nature, pianist and listeners settle again and the symphony for piano ends with a joyful and grateful feeling. A wonderful recording.

Piano arrangements mirror orchestral works in their pure, uncoloured form. Liszt did much more: he traced the orchestral sound brilliantly and burst the corset of the simple, conventional transcription. The German-based US pianist Claire Huangci shows her joy at the arrival in the countryside as if on a radiantly fresh morning, and just as I already admired in her Scarlatti album, her playing in this much more complex score is also marked by transparency, flawlessly pedalless themes that are carefully developed emotionally. Every movement — also the wild peasants' dance or the storm awaited with suspense — recalls an accomplished performance in historically informed reading. Convincing! From now on I will reach for this sonorous studio recording when I want to hear the Liszt version.

Ludwig Flich, HiFi+ Records, 2021

After the noteworthy complete recordings of the Chopin Nocturnes and the Rachmaninoff Préludes, pianist Claire Huangci has once again turned to an arrangement for her current project: the piano transcription of Beethoven's 6th Symphony by Franz Liszt. Despite the arrangement being entirely rooted in the style of virtuosity, the musician succeeds in a sensitively balanced dramaturgy of eruptive shaping and contemplative pause — unagitated and refreshingly without grand gesture. (Featured as No. 2 in the Klassik Top 5 CDs.)

cru, Journal Frankfurt, 2021

As the transcription of Beethoven's Pastorale shows, Liszt succeeds very well in representing the many interacting sounds of different instruments on the piano alone. Orchestral tuttis become powerful clouds of sound supported by ample pedal use. The fine melodies of the woodwinds appear almost pointillistically as individual lines in the left hand. Liszt's transcriptions are much more — not merely a tool, but through their inherent virtuosity and sonic power, an independent work of art in their own right.

Felix Werthschulte, SWR2 Musikstück der Woche, 2021

Tracklist

  1. 1
    Beethoven (arr. Liszt): Symphony No. 6 'Pastorale', Op. 68I. Erwachen heiterer Empfindungen bei der Ankunft auf dem Lande. Allegro ma non troppo
    9:59
  2. 2
    Beethoven (arr. Liszt): Symphony No. 6 'Pastorale', Op. 68II. Szene am Bach. Andante molto moto
    12:30
  3. 3
    Beethoven (arr. Liszt): Symphony No. 6 'Pastorale', Op. 68III. Lustiges Zusammensein der Landleute. Allegro
    4:47
  4. 4
    Beethoven (arr. Liszt): Symphony No. 6 'Pastorale', Op. 68IV. Gewitter. Sturm. Allegro
    3:52
  5. 5
    Beethoven (arr. Liszt): Symphony No. 6 'Pastorale', Op. 68V. Hirtengesang. Frohe und dankbare Gefühle nach dem Sturm. Allegretto
    9:34